Episode 147 - Must I Accept My Friend's Rebuke? (Transcript)
There is someone in my life who offers me tokhehah regularly that I do not agree with, and frequently asks me to do teshuvah. After many years, this feels more like a call-out than anything else, and it's become one of the only conversations we have at this point. We once had a friendship, but we are not really friends anymore. Do I have to hear them out each time they ask me to do teshuvah?
Visit Hadar.org for more content and podcasts!
---------------------------------------------------------------
Click here for the sources presented in this episode
---------------------------------------------------------------
Rav Avi: Welcome to Responsa Radio, where you ask and we answer questions of Jewish law in modern times. I'm Rabbi Avi Killip, Executive Vice President at Hadar, here with Rabbi Ethan Tucker, Rosh Yeshivah at Hadar, a center for Jewish learning and community building based in New York City. You can check us out and learn more at hadar.org. We have a really rich question today. The question is about a concept called tochachah, which I think maybe we need just a one-word or one-sentence definition of before we do the question. Do you want to do that for us?
Rav Ethan: Sometimes you'll see "rebuke" or "reproof" as translations, but essentially it means calling someone out on something that they're doing wrong and that's upsetting you.
Rav Avi: And telling them directly.
Rav Ethan: That's right. Telling them directly.
Rav Avi: Okay. So the question arrives: "There is someone in my life who offers me tochachah regularly that I do not agree with, and frequently asks me to do teshuvah. After many years, this feels more like a call-out than anything else, and it's become one of the only conversations we have at this point. We once had a friendship, but we are not really friends anymore. Do I have to hear them out each time they ask me to do teshuvah?"
Rav Avi: So I think we did a question that had echoes of this once, that was like, do I have to forgive someone who keeps asking me for forgiveness? This is a different angle on the teshuvah question. I think we probably want to start from a place of better understanding this idea of tochachah, the mitzvah of tochachah. Even the way the English is phrased in the question, "there's someone in my life who offers me"—like it's a gift, you know. It's not a concept that I grew up with. I think I only learned about it later in my Jewish life. I don't remember being taught it in kindergarten. So maybe give us a little bit of a 101 on what tochachah is, and then we can try to dig into the receiving of tochachah.
Rav Ethan: Yeah. I will just say it's sad. In other words, the question is sad. It's sad hearing about friendships that run aground on what sometimes are just different ways of seeing the world, or of understanding how someone moves through it. So I'm just noting that. But I agree, I think the way to begin here is: let's get a handle on this mitzvah, and then we can figure out what the role of the different players is and how we can be helpful in this case and others.
Rav Ethan: It's a good one. I love it when there's just a verse that says something. So this is from Vayikra chapter 19, verse 17: Lo tisna et achikha bilvavekha, hokhe'ach tokhi'ach et amitekha, velo tisa alav chet. Don't hate your fellow in your heart. Rather, rebuke, rebuke your friend—
Rav Avi: It's a double.
Rav Ethan: Yeah, we get the double. And don't bear sin on their account. All right, so we could do an hour just sitting with the syntax of the verse.
Rav Avi: I don't know—if I just read it and hear it, this is a verse that says, hey, it's bad to bottle things up. You will have guilt for bottling something up about someone else. Just let it out there and tell me. It's sort of like: rebuke, if the alternative would be hatred. And also, the sin here sounds like you might do something worse than rebuke. Like, rebuke rather than punch them in the face. It's like with children, where we might say, use your words. Tell him he made you angry; don't hit him. This is maybe the grown-up version of that.
Rav Ethan: Yeah, I think it can be read that way. I do think that doubled verb might already be pushing us to a notion of: that part of the verse is independently important. Do it. No, really, do it. Because it's not just "don't bottle it up, let it out." It's "actually, you should do this." And particularly if you read the end of the verse, velo tisa alav chet, as "and thereby you will not have borne sin on this person's account," you could read it as: when someone else is doing something wrong, if you don't rebuke them, you're kind of responsible for the fact that they continue to do things that are wrong.
Rav Avi: Do you think that's the plain meaning of it? Or is it "don't punch them in the face"—my version?
Rav Ethan: I think "don't punch them in the face" feels intuitive on an emotional level. But when I look at the syntax: whose is the sin? Is the sin their sin, which will become your problem? Or is the sin you doing something wrong by bottling something up? I think the part that argues—at least for the possibility, if not the plausibility—that it's their sin is: was it really a sin to bottle something up?
Rav Avi: Right. I could think of a third option, which is: I'll sin by attacking you or harming you instead of giving rebuke. And it also might be—we live in this world of relay hatred, right? Where it's like, well, if you hate me, I'll hate the next person. And this could also be: actually, give the rebuke, rather than become a sinful person who perpetuates the bad behavior in some other direction, who lets it out in some other way. It feels like it's a release. It makes me want to read the doubling as "and you're allowed to yell while you rebuke them."
Rav Ethan: Yeah. And look, I think what's at stake here on some level is: is there a mitzvah to rebuke separate from hating someone in your heart?
Rav Avi: I mean, if you weren't going to hate them in your heart, you don't have to rebuke them?
Rav Ethan: Yeah—like, what if I'm not agitated? If it's just "don't punch them in the face," it might be: oh, then I wasn't talking to you. Whereas the alternative reading of hokhe'ach tokhi'ach is: hey, don't hate someone in your heart, because that probably means there's something they're doing that's wrong. And now let me give you some general guidance: when someone's doing something wrong, you actually have an obligation—as their fellow, as a fellow Jew, as a fellow human being—to rebuke them, because you are responsible for other people's wrongdoings. That reading will get you to a stronger footing of: you've got to actually make a difference in the moral balance of the world by stepping up here. So I think we see embedded in the verse a little bit of ambiguity about which direction we should take it. But one way or the other, the double verb hokhe'ach tokhi'ach definitely suggests there's something strong and important there that has to happen.
Rav Ethan: Two other verses here, I think, relate to the relational piece. These are not from the Torah; they're from Mishlei, the book of Proverbs—general counsel and wisdom, if you will. Two striking things. The first verse, from chapter 9, says: don't rebuke someone who is a letz.
Rav Avi: A fool?
Rav Ethan: You could say a clownish person, a non-serious person, or something like that. We'll see the opposite.
Rav Avi: Is it a fool? Is that how they translate it?
Rav Ethan: Yeah, it can be a fool, because it's going to be the opposite of a chacham, a wise person. Don't rebuke a fool, lest they hate you; but rebuke a wise person, and they will love you. So there's a sense here that tochachah is actually a profound, relationship-altering interaction.
Rav Avi: Well, it's also really striking that this verse connects it to hatred again. There's some connection we haven't quite figured out between hatred and tochachah: you should only do the tochachah if it relieves hatred, but not if it creates hatred.
Rav Ethan: Yeah. And here the hatred switches, right? It was the hatred in your heart that should lead you to rebuke. Here, you rebuke, and that person will hate you.
Rav Avi: Right. According to this verse, it's all dependent on the character of the person being rebuked.
Rav Ethan: Yeah, it's the receiver.
Rav Avi: The same action will land completely differently based on the character of the receiver. You know this because we work together, but I have a book that I found years ago called Thanks for the Feedback. I think the full title is something like Thanks for the Feedback, even when it's unreasonable, off base, and I don't like you anyway—or something like that. But one of the key theses in the book that has really struck me is that the success of feedback is entirely in the hands of the receiver. The best feedback receiver can receive feedback and implement it from anyone, even from the worst giver.
Rav Ethan: And this other verse in Mishlei, I think, reinforces that, in chapter 27, where it says: better open rebuke than concealed love. Which is to say: open rebuke, which feels like the worst thing in the world—actually, at least someone's being honest with you. They're sharing something with you. There's a point of connection. Sure, it's great to be loved openly. But you might think, I'd rather have concealed love. No: feedback. Give me the feedback, one way or the other, that I can hear.
Rav Avi: This is a really interesting verse. It actually feels really relevant to the question. I'm thinking about the part of the question that said, "We once had a friendship, but we're not really friends anymore," and this is all the conversation they have at this point. This verse might point you in the direction of: we don't cut people off. You keep the relationship alive and real—a relationship built on real, honest feedback. If that person still cares enough to be open with you, to continue to give you this feedback, that's actually better than if you loved each other but just grew apart and never talked. It's very unintuitive. It's a real hot take from Proverbs.
Rav Ethan: Yeah. So look, I think we see this is grounded. This is a concept. It's there as some form of mitzvah or expectation, and there's wisdom and direction about how to integrate it into your life. There are other biblical passages we could point to where tochachah seems to play a role—a famous encounter between Avraham and Avimelekh. Avraham's upset about the wells that he feels have been stolen from him, and it says: he rebuked him. And at the end of that story, they make a covenant, a pact. So we also have a picture of what this could look like integrated into a relationship: there's a tough moment of confronting someone, but with the right characters—and interestingly, Avimelekh here seems like he's the right character—you can build something out.
Rav Avi: Yeah. And in that story, the way this text is reading it, without that rebuke they actually wouldn't have had the strength of relationship that they build throughout that story.
Rav Ethan: Yeah. The rabbinic take on this, in the name of Reish Lakish, is: you learn from that story that rebuke leads to peace. Any peace that doesn't have rebuke is not real peace; it's conflict avoidance. Peace is basically: I get it, I upset you this way, we're going to fix that. And now we're actually good. We're not hiding from anything. That's the ideal role of tochachah.
Rav Avi: That sounds beautiful and so important, and so different from the story we have here from the questioner, which is not, "Oh, you helped me see something I didn't see before; now we can get to a deeper, better place."
Rav Ethan: Totally. So, okay, I think now we get sort of what this thing is. The question is: what is its role supposed to be in the world? And what are some of the parameters that the rabbinic tradition lays out? I want to actually start with a debate in aggadah. These are not normative texts in the sense of giving you a ruling; they're normative texts in terms of how they see the world and the role of tochachah and rebuke in it. And they're really very different, so I'm interested to hear your reaction.
Rav Avi: And I think it's important, when we see a question like this, to know that you're going to need to reach for some aggadah, for some stories. Legal analysis alone might not get us there without some case study, or some of the emotional valence in aggadah. And just for the meta version of this podcast: halakhah is never meant to be explored or studied without aggadah, with all due respect to the Rif and the Ein Yaakov. When the Talmud puts halakhah and aggadah about the same topic next to each other, it's because you actually need both.
Rav Ethan: Couldn't agree more. So let me start with the first piece of aggadah. It's well known in rabbinic literature that the book of Devarim, Deuteronomy, the last book of the Torah, is understood to be a kind of mass rebuke of the Jewish people by Moshe. If you read the early chapters there, there's a lot of: you were terrible, mamrim heyitem, you were rebels, you didn't listen to me, and then I had to pray for you. It's a harsh, harsh diatribe. The thing that's striking, though, is that most of what Moshe yells at them about is stuff that happened in the early years in the desert, but the book timestamps the speech in the fortieth year, as he's about to die. It sounds like he's held an incredibly long grudge. So Sifrei Devarim—the midrash on that book, a halakhic midrash, but here it's aggadah—says: we learn from this that Moshe did not rebuke the people until he was about to die. And it says there are four reasons why you do that. Number one: so that you won't do it over and over and over again.
Rav Avi: This is very relevant to our questioner.
Rav Ethan: Two: so that the person you rebuke won't see you and be ashamed every time they see you, because they'll be like, oh my God, that's my rebuker.
Rav Avi: That's my rebuker. Yeah.
Rav Ethan: Three: so that you won't walk around as the rebuker, constantly consumed in your heart by that person—they're terrible, etc. That's in the other direction.
Rav Avi: That's like: every time I see you, I won't be thinking, should I say it now? Should I say it now? I know there's a time and a place, and I will say it then.
Rav Ethan: And most interestingly: so that they can part from one another in peace. That is to say, the image here is that tochachah brings peace. You do that final thing: now I can die, I can get this off my chest, and now I feel fine about you, and I can die and part from you.
Rav Avi: Yeah. Or I was thinking from the other direction: I don't have to move through the world thinking, that person died and I never really knew what she thought of me, or we never worked out that fight we were having. I always knew she had something to say to me, and now I'll never know what she was going to say. You can have peace of mind knowing that you had it out in your last conversation, rather than leaving it unsaid.
Rav Ethan: I think that's right. I think it's an even better reading of the text. So that, I would say, is an aggadah where tochachah should be rare, safe, and legal—some notion of: it's really important, but pick the right moment, and it's got to be in a context where it's safe and productive. The deathbed is one place that can happen.
Rav Avi: It certainly feels almost entirely at odds, these two stories. In one case, the only way Avraham and Avimelekh are going to have a deeper relationship is if the tochachah is given in the moment—the sort of "feedback is best given immediately." This is entirely the opposite. There, tochachah is what will lead you into a real, deeper relationship. And here it's: tochachah will break your relationship, so wait until you're parting.
Rav Ethan: Yeah, because it will be broken otherwise. And there's another opposite here, which is the second aggadah. It points us not only to the fact that if you don't do tochachah, you're missing out on building the relationship—we could go even further with this text. This is in the Talmud Bavli, in Shabbat. Here, in a chain of sages in the name of Rabbi Chanina, they say: you know why Jerusalem was destroyed? Because they didn't give tochachah to one another. It describes the entire generation at the end of the Second Temple period as people who were kavshu peneihem bakarka, which literally means they pressed their faces into the ground—their heads were in the sand. They avoided looking at and confronting one another. And as a result, the Temple was destroyed and Jerusalem burned. What do you make of this? Let's just pause here for a minute. Two rabbinic texts—one's from the land of Israel, one's from Babylonia, we can divide it up however we want. One says: tochachah, you've got to wait for the right moment; it really should not be so common, and it shouldn't be repeated. And here: a society without tochachah will burn.
Rav Avi: Yeah. Well, here's what I'll pull out as a thread that I see in both, even though I'm not sure where it would leave me in terms of how I should behave: tochachah is inextricably linked up with relationship. These sources do not feel to me like "I should rebuke you so you'll stop doing the bad behavior." There's something relational about it, and I either need to do it or not do it for the sake of the relationship. And maybe that's the takeaway: start from the question of, if I want the relationship to flourish, will it flourish? Will I be more in relationship if I give you the tochachah, or more in relationship if I don't? And in the Temple example, people were so out of relationship with each other that the text is assuming that tochachah is what would bring them into relationship. It still feels a little surprising to me. I might have said everyone was staring at the ground and what was missing was love.
Rav Ethan: Right.
Rav Avi: Or people weren't helping each other, or chesed was missing. It's interesting that the choice of what was missing is rebuke.
Rav Ethan: And there are other traditions there that definitely blame the destruction on other things. But yes, this one is saying there's something essential about that rebuke. It's interesting—I hear you almost saying that maybe you could read this as: it's not that tochachah is the essential piece here. Because tochachah is so essential to relationship, what you see is that if there was zero tochachah, there wasn't relationship, and the relationship collapsing somehow led the society to collapse.
Rav Avi: Yeah. So I was going to ask about public versus private. My assumption is that the conversation this questioner is having is a private, one-on-one tochachah that's coming at them. But especially with the text that you brought us—the Temple is destroyed because everyone's keeping their heads down, and if only people were giving tochachah it would be different—I feel like society as a whole in America has really bought into that idea. I'll say it in the cheekiest way: if everyone would just post on social media about all the bad things they think should be different, the world would be better. "Oh, I forgot to post about how bad it is that this car is parked here, and that this war is happening, and that this politician said this sentence that I don't like." And then: "I don't understand, why aren't more people speaking out on this?" As if everybody posting on social media about something is somehow going to make our society better or make us better connected. That's maybe a really cheeky way to put it, but obviously there's some version of that that this text, I think, is trying to tell us.
Rav Ethan: This, I think, is actually a great segue into some of the other texts here that fill this out.
Rav Avi: You have a text about social media posting?
Rav Ethan: I think I have something that's sort of like it. We'll see—you'll tell me. And we'll get to the public-private question in a little bit. The Sifra, the early halakhic midrash on Vayikra, says the following on this verse—I'm summarizing here. You know that doubled verb, hokhe'ach tokhi'ach, that we saw in the verse—rebuke, rebuke? That teaches you that even if you've done it four or five times, you've got to keep going. Elsewhere in the Talmud, it'll say even a hundred times. So the relentlessness that the questioner is experiencing is actually one of the parameters of the mitzvah as understood in rabbinic sources.
Rav Avi: Completely at odds with Moshe, who did it only once.
Rav Ethan: Yes. It seems like that aggadah and this halakhah didn't meet each other. They may be from different schools. Who knows? But then here's a follow-up, which maybe is helpful. Could it be that you're supposed to do it even if—and I love this image—even if you rebuke them, ufanav mishtanot, and the person's face changes? They heard it, but they're maybe blanching, or cringing. You say the thing, you provide the feedback, as it were—and you've had this experience—and you're like, oh boy, that person took it the wrong way.
Rav Avi: Do you think it's "took it the wrong way," or could it also be the right way? You communicated it, and they got it.
Rav Ethan: It could be. But here the verse is understood to say: could it be that you should give tochachah even when their face is going to change? Velo tisa alav chet—don't bear sin on their account. This is now a radical rereading of the verse. What are we saying? Rebuke someone, but if you do it in a way where their face changes, you will actually be sinful for having done it wrong. Something like that. The sages then go on to say: in this generation—Rabbi Tarfon says—no one has the capacity to do this.
Rav Avi: To receive it or to give it?
Rav Ethan: To give it. Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah says no one in this generation has the capacity to receive it. And Rabbi Akiva says no one in this generation knows how to do it. That is to say, neither party has the fortitude to give it or withstand it, nor is anyone skilled in how to do it. And then you get this story, which almost confirms this by being so exceptional. Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri says: I constantly rebuked Rabbi Akiva in front of Rabban Gamliel, over and over and over—I can't tell you how much aggravation I caused him. But I swear to you, every time I did it, he loved me more. Clearly something amazing happened: Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri knew how to give, and Rabbi Akiva knew how to receive. And even though it wasn't totally private—there was a bit of a public element, with Rabban Gamliel—it was successful. But the extraordinary nature of the story seems to say that most people are completely incapable of this. And there does seem to be a thrust of: if you are going to end up making the person feel like "I hate talking to that person, I just feel worse, I don't feel at all motivated about where to go from here," the mitzvah doesn't apply anymore. It might even be forbidden to do it.
Rav Avi: Yeah. So one way to respond to the story would be: oh, okay, this is a mitzvah that's just for exceptional people. There are some exceptional people in the world who can give tochachah, and those people should, because they're the only ones who can. When they speak, they have the ability to say something in a way that people can hear it, and so they should be doing that. That's maybe one way to read it. I'm always so struck—I get hung up on "we're doing halakhah for our time." So any time I hear the rabbis of the Talmud saying "in our time," it makes me want to either say, oh, they already couldn't do it then—or, that was their time, but maybe we can do it now. Maybe we live in a post-on-Facebook world and they didn't, and we actually live in a call-out, feedback world. Just because they couldn't do it doesn't necessarily mean that we can't.
Rav Ethan: Right. So this is where you asked, do you have a text about social media? A little bit, though I feel confused as to which direction it goes. On the one hand, yes, there's a culture now that does that, and it's accepted. But I also look at that and think: that seems mostly terrible. That seems mostly like encouraging tisna et achikha bilvavekha—getting more people to hate each other in their hearts than ever before.
Rav Avi: And I think a key element of that story that I would want to pull out, which makes social media a bad way to do tochachah, is that I can't see if your face changed. If I can't see your face when I give the tochachah, then I don't know whether I'm hurting you or not, or how it's being received. That maybe makes it too dangerous.
Rav Ethan: I love that. I really love that. I think there's something very profound there about the ground conditions for what makes this possible. I do want to zigzag us to another piece here, though, which again I'm not sure exactly what to do with, and I don't know how it adds up with the other sources. So we've seen, on the one hand, this relentlessness—over and over and over, a hundred times. On the other hand, we saw: but don't make the person's face change. And that has a sort of corollary tradition, a statement by Rabbi Elazar b'Rabbi Shimon, who says: just as there's a mitzvah to say things that will be heard, there's a mitzvah not to say things that won't be heard. And that goes to your point about who's skilled at this.
Rav Avi: Maybe pulling us back to: what's the relationship? Know the relationship. Is this going to work?
Rav Ethan: Then you have this sort of powerful, arresting text in the Talmud, in Arakhin. They ask: how far do you have to go with tochachah? This isn't about the number of times, but about the intensity of the interaction.
Rav Avi: How loudly should I yell?
Rav Ethan: Yeah—or how far do I press it, and before what kind of reaction? So it's amazing: they go to a scene that we read as the haftarah when Shabbat falls the day before Rosh Chodesh, where you're getting the beginning of basically the blood feud between David and Shaul. Shaul is still the king. David is negotiating the relationship, but Shaul already has a sense that David's going to replace him. Yehonatan, Shaul's son, is very close friends with David. And then you have this scene where David doesn't show up to a royal meal where he's expected.
Rav Avi: It could be a telenovela.
Rav Ethan: If you haven't read it, you should watch the show. It's great. Shaul bursts out on the second day, when David hasn't shown up two days in a row, and says very insultingly: why didn't ben Yishai come to the meal today or yesterday? And "ben Yishai"—dropping the person's name—is how you insult someone.
Rav Avi: Right. Okay.
Rav Ethan: At that moment, Yehonatan says: no, what do you mean? He went to his family; he just couldn't be here. Not really true, but he protects him, and he rebukes Shaul in this moment—that's the understanding. He's like, no, Dad, that's not right. Then what happens? It says Shaul was furious. He basically curses Yehonatan—you scoundrel—and picks up a spear and throws it at Yehonatan, and misses, but basically threatening to hit him or kill him. So three sages, Rav, Shmuel and Rabbi Yochanan, corresponding to three earlier Tannaim—
Rav Avi: They had a watch party of this show.
Rav Ethan: After the watch party, they all read this verse and say: this verse teaches us the extent to which you have to go when giving tochachah. Rabbi Yochanan says: you see, Yehonatan was prepared to do it until Shaul got angry. So actually, you give tochachah until the person starts to get angry at you. Shmuel says: no, actually, Shaul didn't just get angry—he cursed Yehonatan. You actually have to go beyond the anger boundary, to when someone says, you know, shut the four-letter-word up, or whatever it is. And Rav says: no, you guys don't get it. He threatened to kill him. He was picking up a spear. That's the moment you have to go up to.
Rav Avi: Wow.
Rav Ethan: So those are very different endpoints, but they're all pushing in the direction of: you actually have to go at least to the level of ticking someone off, and maybe beyond.
Rav Avi: So for this, we might say to our questioner: your tochachah giver is actually just getting started. They've only gotten you to the point of making you angry. There are no curse words in this question, and they aren't saying, "I might murder this person; should I keep meeting with them?" So we're not even close to the line. But—and maybe you can help with a little more nuance—are they saying that even if it puts your life at risk you have to give tochachah? Or are they saying you should make the person upset? Is there a value in making the person upset?
Rav Ethan: No, I don't think there's a value in it. But the question is: how far do you have to push? What do you have to be prepared to bear in the unpleasantness of the interaction?
Rav Avi: It makes me think of my non-biblical, non-Jewish source, the feedback book: is somebody who is that upset able to hear your tochachah?
Rav Ethan: Okay, so here—if you imagine, how do you codify a text like this? This is what the Rambam is sort of amazing at. His Hilkhot De'ot is essentially an entire codification of virtue ethics: how do I behave in the world? So he tries to make sense of all of this. Listen to the language he pulls together; I think it's striking, all the different components here. If you see someone going down a bad path, you've got to try to bring them back to the good path. Tell them: you're sinning, that's wrong, this is not the way you should behave. That's the mitzvah. And here he gives the guidance for how you do it in relationship: you have to say it softly and gently. You actually have to be clear: I'm only telling you this for your own good; I want you to get your olam haba, your world to come. And ideally, says the Rambam, the person receives that and accepts it. If they don't—
Rav Avi: You throw a spear at their head.
Rav Ethan: If they don't buy in, you've got to go back a second time, a third time, ad infinitum—until, and he codifies Rav's strictest position, until he hits you and says, I am not going to listen to you. So the Rambam says you've got to object. And why do you have to object? What is this all based on? If you have the ability to stop someone else from sinning and you don't stop them, you are culpable. So until you're actually in physical danger from the rebuke, you must do this.
Rav Avi: Well, it also feels like: until they stop taking your calls. In the frame of our modern question, it would almost be that you actually have to stop having these conversations with the person, because they can't stop. Again, if we take both people as people who are trying to do the right thing: okay, we have a disagreement about whether you did anything wrong. But they think you did something wrong, so they actually have to keep giving you tochachah until you reach the point where you say, "I'm not listening to you anymore. I deleted you from my phone, and I don't take your calls anymore." That may be a hard thing for this listener to do. But according to this text, that person actually has to keep giving the tochachah until you cut them off. So you have to decide when you've reached that point.
Rav Ethan: I think that's right. And even if you don't follow the Rambam—the Sefer Mitzvot Gadol, the SMaG, doesn't go with Rav's position. He goes with Rabbi Yochanan's position, which is just displaying anger; you don't have to actually be threatening to hit the person. But there's still a notion that the other person, as you say, if they're taking the mitzvah of tochachah seriously, will find it hard to justify stopping until you give them a cue that this is not going anywhere. And so, yes: someone might say to you, "You just did that thing, I really disapprove, you shouldn't have done it," and you might have to say, "I'm sorry, that's preposterous. I don't accept that. Please don't raise it with me anymore." At that point, it actually becomes problematic for the rebuker to continue. So yes, I think you're right to point to the fact that there may actually be some obligation on the person receiving the rebuke—assuming they shouldn't be taking in the rebuke. I don't know the case. It could be that if we were sitting down with our questioner, we would say: you know, there actually is something here you should be taking in. But just within the frame of the question, there might be some obligation on you to put an end to the process.
Rav Avi: This requirement to give tochachah feels like it's actually ongoing until one of two things happens. Either they heard you and did teshuvah, in which case you must stop. Or they became enraged and violent, in which case you must stop. Those are the endpoints, and until you reach them, maybe you actually are supposed to keep going.
Rav Ethan: Yeah. The only caveat I'll give for that—
Rav Avi: But in a quiet and respectful way.
Rav Ethan: Yeah, because that's the thing about the face changing, right? When the Rambam uses that language—you've got to be very gentle and quiet—that's his codification of "don't make their face change." If you're going to yell at them, people have an almost involuntary chemical response when they're yelled at: they get defensive. Or there can be shaming. Panav mishtanot often literally means the color drains from their face. That cannot be what is happening here. So to the extent that the tone of these interactions was never right, this tochachah never should have been given on those terms. And the other wild card is those rabbis saying that in our generation no one knows how to do this. That potentially also means that in our generation people shouldn't give tochachah, because they don't know how, and people don't know how to receive it. And so it's just a dumpster fire—it's almost actually forbidden.
Rav Ethan: So that's the trickier thing. And that's where I think those early aggadot feel important, because they remind us: you cannot abandon this mitzvah entirely just because of sensitivities, because otherwise, as it were, Jerusalem may be destroyed. But on the other hand, even Moshe Rabbeinu, in the most self-evident position of seniority and righteousness, had the seikhel to basically say: when is this going to land well? The fact that it's agitating me does not mean that this is the moment to let it out. You've got to sit somewhere on that spectrum.
Rav Avi: I really like what you said before: that the barometer you should really be using is your understanding of the relationship, and where you're hoping and expecting it to go.
Rav Ethan: Tochachah that comes from a place of "I've got to get this off my chest, and that's my responsibility"—there is a strand of that: well, you'll be responsible, I get it. But even the Rambam, who's doubling down on "you will be responsible for other people's missteps," is only saying you'll be responsible if you had a pathway to changing it. Why don't you check first whether you really have a pathway to changing it?
Rav Avi: I think this is all really important. On the one hand, it's sort of frustrating: I wanted a yes or no answer. I wanted a really clear answer to when tochachah is good, and when it's bad, and when it's harmful, and when it's dangerous. And actually, that's not how a lot of life works. A lot of life, and a lot of halakhah, is saying: here are the things you need to consider. How much good can it do? How much harm can it do? What are the risks? What are the benefits? And maybe one major takeaway we're pulling out here is: it's not about you and it's not about them; it's about the relationship. There has to be at least the possibility that this is going to make you closer in the end. If you can't even see a possibility that giving this tochachah is going to make you closer, then that's not really what the mitzvah of tochachah is about.
Rav Ethan: And that's where the repeating, I think, becomes complicated, because in principle the repeating is a core part of this mitzvah, and the fact that you did not succeed the first time does not exempt you from trying again. But here too, some degree of common sense applies. If you know the person, and you know they're not the kind of person who listens the fifth time as opposed to the fourth time, you may already know for yourself that you've pushed this as far as it can go.
Rav Avi: And/or the inverse. You might say: I know that I told them this when we were in college, and I told them this again when we were in our thirties, but I think they may be able to hear it now in a way that they couldn't then. So I'm going to try again.
Rav Ethan: That's right. I think the best answer, as it were, that we can give the questioner—I'll give two points I'm feeling, and you can fill in anything else. Number one, without knowing the case: look deep into your heart. Just make sure that the way in which this person is being annoying to you is not occluding your vision of something that maybe you do have some ability to improve or repair. That's just a core piece, as you say, of developing the kind of character where we are the chacham who can take it and can grow as a result.
Rav Avi: And when you can do that, you can do it even with the worst feedback giver.
Rav Ethan: That's right. That's what it is to be wise, to be the chacham, in this context. And the second piece, which you really drew out, and which I think is important: you may have a role to play here in ending this story. You're not just there asking, do I suffer or not? Is it a binary of either I'm in this relationship and they're rebuking me, or I end the relationship? It may be that you say: "I am not going to listen to that rebuke anymore. Thanks for offering it, but it's not going to land. So we can either move forward with a relationship that has retired that, or we won't have one." It could actually be that you, the questioner, have some role in bringing about that next stage.
Rav Avi: Yeah, in one direction or the other—either through doing teshuvah, or through saying, we're done here.
Rav Ethan: Yeah.
Rav Avi: I hope this is helpful. I can just imagine that all of our listeners heard this episode with a different track playing in the back of their minds, of some situation they're in, whichever side they're on, giver or receiver. I hope that some of the sources and stories we brought here are helpful. And I just want to end where you started, by saying: it's really sad, and it's really hard. There are so many things in life that are sad and hard, and relationships that break around misalignment on tochachah and teshuvah are some of the really heartbreaking ones. So if you are a listener holding whatever that sad, hard story is for you, I just want to acknowledge that, and to say: I hope you can find something in the sources we brought to help you through it.
Have a halakhic question you'd like answered on the show? Email us at [email protected].
Responsa Radio is a project of the Hadar Institute. Thanks to Chana Kupetz and Jeremy Tabick for producing this podcast and to David Khabinsky for recording and editing this episode.